Chichi-Okobee and his men stood in front of the camp of De Soto, the Great White Chief. Two of the guards, equipped with helmets and shields, drew their swords at the Prince of the Seminoles. The word then broke out: Chichi-Okobee ordered for a peace deal to the Great White Chief. Instead, they held him captive in the Everglades.
Despite everything, Chichi-Okobee would soon fall in love with the daughter of the Great White Chief: Sara. But soon, disaster would strike. Due to the lack of food and modern medicine that Chichi-Okobee received during his captivation in the Everglades, he soon fell ill. In efforts to save Chichi-Okobee, the doctors from the Spanish camp gave up. Sara begged to be with Chichi in his final hours. The love connection between Chichi and Sara was strong, and it cured Chichi, but Sara fell ill.
Chichi begged to go to his father's camp to retrieve the medicine man, Ahti. Days later Chichi came back with Ahti and stood in front of the tent of Sara De Soto. Ahti tried desperately to help the sick and dying girl, but it was no use. Sara was dead. Both Chichi and the Great White Chief mourned her death.
The Chief let Chichi choose the spot of where her daughter would lay to rest for the rest of time. She would be buried by the bay, accompanied by the Great White Chief, Chichi and his one hundred Seminole Guardsmen. Today, Sarasota Bay is known for projecting the love story of a Seminole Chief and a young Spaniard, with stories and folklore being told from generation to generation. In the end, it was believed that the spirits of Chichi-Okobee and his men are in an eternal hell of conflict between the evil spirits and children of the storm god to project the resting spot of Sara De Soto.